Dr. Michael Ciampi announced on April 1st that he would no
longer be accepting insurance in any form as payment for his services.
But this was no April Fool's joke: Dr. Ciampi says he
decided to cut out the middleman and deal directly with his patients.
He even posted a price list on his website — from brief
visits ($50) to complete physicals ($150) to minor surgery ($200-$250).
Though he did lose a few hundred patients out of about
2,000, Ciampi told the Bangor Daily News that the new policy has allowed him to
reduce his overhead and pass the savings on to the consumer.
"I’m freed up to do what I think is right for the patients," said Ciampi, who is now able to make house calls and even negotiate discounts for patients with financial hardships.
The doctor understands that some patients with insurance
might find the hassle of having to seek reimbursement themselves too difficult
and would opt for another PCP, but he fully expects to make up for the loss by
attracting the self-employed and individuals without insurance or with
unacceptably high deductibles.
Or even just people looking for a bargain: At least one
patient who was being charged $160 per office visit before is now paying less
than half that.
And Ciampi hopes this is just the beginning.
"If more doctors were able to do this, that would be
real health care reform," he is quoted as saying. "That’s when we’d
see the cost of medicine truly go down."
If you turned on the news over the holiday weekend, chances
are you saw something about the looming disaster called Obamacare. This is
because, as the Heritage Foundation put it, "Last week, the Obama
Administration attempted to spin its announcement of a one-year delay in
Obamacare's employer mandate as an effort to implement the law 'in a careful,
thoughtful manner.' Don't be fooled. Even Democrats have admitted the law has
turned into a massive 'train wreck,' with delays, glitches, and problems
aplenty."
Meanwhile, Michael Ciampi, a family doctor in Maine was able
to reduce his prices and improve service by no longer accepting health
insurance. I strongly encourage you to read this article explaining Ciampi's
own personal attempt at health care reform.
Dr. Ciampi shared with us an important letter he sent to
close friends and family when he decided to change the structure of his
practice. Here is what it said…
We have decided to make some radical changes in our
practice. I have a feeling people may be very curious to know why, so I thought
I would give an in-depth explanation.
My father got out of medicine in 1999 in part because of an
ever increasing amount of paperwork and requirements put on him by the
government and insurance companies. Unfortunately, since he retired, they have
gotten exponentially worse. We have to spend a lot of time and money filling
out forms, maintaining very expensive software systems, and constantly dealing
with prior authorization requests, and appealing denials for services that we
have provided in good faith, etc.
We have never been able to accept Medicaid patients because
that population in general requires a lot of intense care, but the state (under
both Democrat and Republican administrations) pays little or nothing. With
their rules and requirements, we would have actually lost a fair amount of
money for every patient we would have seen on Medicaid. It has been easier for
us to see established patients who go on Medicaid for free, and hope they get
regular insurance back at some point in the future.
Medicare has been a little better, but they have not
increased their reimbursement rates in about 10 years or so. Every 6-12 months,
an automatic formula, the SGR (Sustained Growth Ratio?), which was established
by Clinton/Gingrich, mandates that Medicare rates be reduced in order to keep
Medicare spending flat. Each time a cut is looming, Congress, usually at the
last minute (or sometimes a few weeks retroactively), postpones the cut. Each
time they do, the next time it comes up, the cut is even deeper. This past New
Years, with the whole fiscal cliff fiasco, the cut would have been over 26%. It
was postponed, but will likely be close to 30% the next time it comes up at the
end of the year. We are currently being paid 30 cents on the dollar by Medicare.
Our revue has been flat for 10 years. Our expenses have gone up by at least 30%
or more.
With no end of this vicious cycle in sight, we cannot make
any long term plans. We work to cut our overhead as much as we can, but we are
getting to the point that we cannot anymore if we are to meet all the
regulatory requirements placed on us, and still pay our employees, pay for
their insurance, and maintain a practice that people would want to come to (You
can only lower the heat so much).
The commercial insurance companies are not much better. They
base most of their payments on Medicare rates. They pay more, but they also
require us to do more paperwork to get the money.
All these things have been going on for years. They have
made it very hard to stay in practice. The upcoming implementation of Obamacare
was the last straw for us, both financially and ethically.
When we established our independent practice, we joined the
Maine Health Physicians Health Organization. It started as a collaborative so
that small practices could do collective bargaining with big insurance
companies, and to share experience and resources. The organization has changed.
Instead of working for the physicians, they take the view that the physicians
work for them. This organization now requires all member to be part of the
"Accountable Care Organization" (ACO) model which was established
under Obamacare. We believe that it is immoral and we will not participate.
Because of this, we are being forced out of the organization.
FYI: The way an ACO supposedly works is that for every
patient that consents to be in this program, Medicare gives Maine Health (Maine
Medical Center's parent organization) a lump sum of money per year. If the
doctors and Maine Medical Center spend less than that sum on the patient, they
split the profit. If they spend more, the doctor and MMC must pay Medicare the
difference. We cannot afford to take on this risk given that our profit margin
is non-existent.
The stated goal of this program is to save money by forcing
the hospitals and doctors to take better and more efficient care of patients.
What is more likely to happen is that doctors and hospitals will start cherry
picking only the healthiest patients to take care of, and do everything they
can to limit the amount of medicine and care they give to the oldest and
sickest of patients. We refuse to cooperate with such a system.
We have done a lot of research and thinking. We looked at
the concierge model, where a patient pays $1500-$2000 per year to a doctor as a
retainer fee, then has to pay for visits on top of this. If you succeed, it is
very profitable, but that is not what we were comfortable doing.
After having worked as an employee of a hospital owned
practice in the past, and hearing how unhappy my colleagues are that continue
to work in "big box" medical practices, I would never go back to
that. They are not treated with respect by their administrative overlords. They
are constantly being pushed to see more and more patients and charge as much as
they can. This may be good for the practice's bottom line, but it is not what I
would consider good medicine. I even talked to a doctor at the VA about their
system, but they have it even worse.
We decided that the right thing for us was to go to the
direct pay model. It is really the way medicine had worked for thousands of
years, up until the past few decades. It will reduce our overhead a great deal.
We do not expect to get rich doing this, but we are hopeful that we can do well
enough to stay in business and be happier.
I know this is a long rant, but I thought it better to give
more details than less. I have done my best to make this as non-political as
possible. Both parties are to blame for the situation.
That being said, I am convinced that Obamacare will make it
much worse. In fact, I believe that it was actually designed to fail. When it
does, and there are no more insurance companies left in business, and we truly
have a health care crisis, they will institute socialized medicine. Some may
welcome this, but those systems do not work, and many countries that have them,
including Canada and Great Britain, are trying to find ways to increase
privatized health care. It is my intention to skip this entire mess, and start
working for patients directly right away.
I am done with my rant.
Source: Bangor Daily News By Dr. Michael Ciampi Monday, July 08, 2013 Maine Doctor Shares
Reasons for No Longer Accepting Health Insurance or Medicare sent via email from
Victoria Edge, Jacksonville FL
No comments:
Post a Comment