Wednesday, February 3, 2016

Texas Muslim Invasion

So it begins here: U.S. city 'overrun' with criminal refugees, 'We've got 42 languages being fielded by our 9-1-1 call centers', by Leo Hohmann, 2/2/16, WND

More than 120 people braved the snow and ice Monday to rally in front of the Missoula County Courthouse, protesting an effort by the Obama administration and its army of community organizers to plant foreign “refugees” into small cities in western Montana.

One of the speakers was a woman who moved recently to Montana from Amarillo, Texas, which has been inundated with thousands of refugees over the past 15 years.

“Amarillo is overrun with refugees,” said Karen Sherman, who stood and spoke to the crowd amid blowing wind and falling snowflakes. Sherman just moved to Missoula, a college town that serves as home to the University of Montana.

It’s a far cry from Amarillo, which she described as a city of rampant crime and cracking social fabric, thanks to the heavy influx of refugees sent there by the U.S. State Department in cooperation with the United Nations.

“Our city is failing because of the refugees. We have 22 different languages spoken in our schools. We’ve got 42 languages being fielded by our 9-1-1 call centers, and crime is just through the roof. We need to exercise caution, especially for the sake of our children,” she said.
The protesters carried signs that read, “Christian Refugees 2 Christian Nations, Muslim Refugees 2 Muslim Nations, That’s Only Fair,” and “Refugee Resettlement Means Big $$$$$ – No Accountability.”

Sherman said Amarillo, a city of just more than 200,000 people, has gang violence that has surpassed that of much larger Texas cities such as Fort Worth. She fears U.S. cities like Amarillo and Minneapolis, Minnesota, could be in line to become the next Rotherham, England, or Cologne, Germany, or Stockholm, Sweden, where mass rapes by Muslim men have gained much attention in Europe.

Touching off a rape epidemic
Amarillo was recently named the fifth most dangerous city in Texas, according to FBI crime statistics, up from sixth last year. And it has been nationally recognized as having one of the highest rates of rape in the nation.

That’s a dubious distinction that Sherman believes is tied to the high number of Muslim refugees shipped there by the U.S. government.

“The rape epidemic in this world is becoming pandemic. It’s not confined to one location. Fifteen years ago in Norway, rape was unheard of. Now it’s an epidemic,” Sherman said. “The perpetrators are 100 percent Muslim males. In Sweden, rape has gone up by 500 percent. Stockholm recently had the dubious honor of opening their very first rape center for men and boys.”

In the northern U.K. city of Rotherham, more than 1,400 children have been beaten, raped and trafficked in a well-documented turn of events that has gone largely unreported in the U.S.

“It was covered up by the local government for fear of being viewed as racist. This only came to light because a journalist decided we needed to know about that, not the government,” she said, referring to the rape scandal that unraveled in England in 2014, when it was revealed by media that gangs of mostly Pakistani men had been sexually assaulting English girls for years while police covered it up for fear of being perceived as “anti-Muslim.” “You can have female equality, or you can have refugees. You cannot have both,” Sherman said.


Too late to save Texas? Texas Gov. Greg Abbot has called for a stop to the influx of refugees, but it’s too late, she said. The program continues unabated because, if even one refugee is present in the U.S., he is entitled under current law to bring in his entire extended family. “It’s called family reunification,” Sherman said.

She said America, founded on Judeo-Christian principles of tolerance and respect for one’s fellow man, should not expect people from Third World cultures to share those values. “If people don’t choose to follow the law, you cannot hire enough police officers,” she said.

“Whether you believe (in the Judeo-Christian God) or not, your values and your principles were influenced by that. Now we’re asking that these people come here, who have been taught for thousands of years of violence and hatred, and we’re expecting them to come here and assimilate to our way of life,” Sherman told the crowd gathered in Missoula. “This is a dangerous and foolish expectation.”

Watch video of Karen Sherman describing the life she left behind in Amarillo, Texas.

Amarillo has received 5,251 foreign refugees since January 2002, according to the
federal refugee database. That's more than half of the nearly 8,000 refugees sent to Texas during that period.

President Obama has increased the number of foreign refugees bound for American soil in fiscal 2016 to 85,000. That's a 20 percent increase over the previous year, and 10,000 will come from the jihadist hotbed of Syria.

WND reported last week that two groups are working to resettle Syrian refugees in Montana. One group, WorldMontana, is working in Helena and the other, Soft Landing Missoula, is working in Missoula.

Caroline Solomon drove more than 100 miles to Missoula Monday from her home in Big Fork, Montana, to participate in the rally.

"About four people (from her group) didn't make it because of weather, but we think there were about 125 people on our side and about six with signs calling us 'racists,'" she said.

Softening up the soil
Soft Landing Missoula is working with city and county officials to bring Third World refugees to Montana while the state's Act For America chapter and other activists are trying to stop that from happening. Soft Landing, like most of the non-governmental organizations working with the government to plant refugees into U.S. cities, is working with churches and faith-based groups behind the scenes to create an atmosphere that is more "welcoming" of refugees.

Many of the community organizers have received training or consultation from David Lubell's Welcoming America organization, which was started with seed money from billionaire George Soros. Lubell is a close adviser to President Obama's "New Americans" initiative, which seeks to convert millions of refugees and recent immigrants into U.S. citizens with full voting privileges.

The modus operandi used by resettlement agencies usually involves sending a handful of refugees at first and then gradually increasing the influx to hundreds per year.
Mary Poole, who represents Soft Landing, Missoula, told KGVO News Radio that many immigrants have settled in Missoula over the past 30 years. She compared the mostly Middle Eastern migrants from Muslim countries like Syria, Afghanistan and Iraq to the Hmong refugees fleeing communist Vietnam in the late 1970s and early '80s.

"We’ve successfully resettled a Hmong community, as well as Belorussians and Ukrainians, who are now members of our community and part of the fabric of Missoula," Poole told KGVO. "We’re just working on revamping the infrastructure that has already existed here."

But according to the federal database, the state of Montana has not received any refugees since 2008, and only 61 have been sent there since the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks.

Montana resistance follows backlash in Idaho
Other small towns in the West have similarly struggled to oppose the plans of urban elites to import what they see as the problems of the Third World into their communities.
In Sandpoint, Idaho, City Council members voted last Wednesday to withdraw a resolution supporting refugee resettlement, bringing an end to a heated, month-long debate over whether that was a wise move. It had the full backing of Sandpoint Mayor Shelby Rognstad.

Cheers erupted from the audience when the newly elected Sandpoint mayor capitulated, asking the council to withdraw his resolution from consideration. His resolution was meant to counter statements from county commissioners and the local sheriff opposing the refugees. Rognstad said his resolution was intended to restate Sandpoint's commitments to "human rights." "This resolution has only served to divide us and this community,” said Rognstad, as he requested the withdrawal. "That saddens me."

But others see the situation in reverse. They see nonprofits and NGOs, often flush with government grant money, coming in and stirring up controversy within their once-peaceful communities.

In Twin Falls, Idaho, Chobani opened the world's largest yogurt factory and gave 30 percent of the 600 jobs to foreign refugees, and the federal government has plans to send 300 more refugees, this time from Syria, to the Twin Falls area. That touched off a backlash from a group called 3 Percent of Idaho, which organized a protest at the Idaho Statehouse in late November that attracted more than 1,000 people from both sides of the issue.

If the past record is any indication, the groups seeking to bring Third World refugees to small town America will not be easily chased off by people with signs.

In fact, the pro-refugee Hebrew Immigrant Aid Society, put together a field manual in 2013 on how to deal with "pockets of resistance" in the American heartland. One of the strategies in that manual is to research the backgrounds of resistors and identify them as "anti-Muslim" racists.

A WND report from May 2015 exposed the HIAS strategy to deride and intimidate any politician or activist who opposes the refuge industry's agenda to change the demographics of a town.

The HIAS report, titled “Resettlement at Risk: Meeting Emerging Challenges to Refugee Resettlement in Local Communities," calls for "new tools to fight back against a determined legislator or governor who has decided to challenge resettlement for political or other reasons."

http://www.wnd.com/2016/02/so-it-begins-here-u-s-city-overrun-with-criminal-refugees/


Gay Wedding Cake Case in Ireland

'Gay' campaigner: I was wrong about Christian bakers, 'I want to defend freedom of conscience, expression and religion', by Bob Unruh, 2/1/16, WND

An appeal hearing is scheduled for Wednesday in a precedent-setting case in Northern Ireland in which a court has ordered Christian bakers to pay damages to a homosexual for refusing to deliver a “gay”-promoting message on a cake.

And just ahead of the hearing in Belfast, a prominent “gay” activist has announced an abrupt reversal in his opinion. He now believes Christians have the right to refuse to provide a message with which they ardently disagree.


They appealed, and the higher court’s hearing is scheduled Wednesday. The two-day hearing was listed by Lord Chief Justice Sir Declan Morgan following a ruling from county Judge Isobel Brownlie that the Christian-owned Asher’s Baking Co. violated the nation’s pro-“gay” provisions by refusing to decorate a cake with a “gay marriage” slogan.
At issue is the bakery’s religious and freedom of speech protections under the European Convention on Human Rights.

Similar cases have arisen in the United States, where courts have fined, penalized, threatened and intimidated Christian business operators, including bakeries in Oregon and Colorado and a photographer in New Mexico for refusing to promote homosexuality with their professional talents, as WND’s Big List of Christian Coercion shows.


The Belfast appeal on behalf of the McArthur family, which owns Ashers Baking Co., was pursued by the Christian Institute. The bakery owners have argued in court they were unaware of any potential customer’s sexual lifestyle choices. They simply could not subscribe to the message.


“Like most gay and equality campaigners, I initially condemned the Christian-run Ashers Bakery in Belfast over its refusal to produce a cake with a pro-gay marriage slogan for a gay customer, Gareth Lee. I supported his legal claim against Ashers and the subsequent verdict – the bakery was found guilty of discrimination last year. Now, two days before the case goes to appeal, I have changed my mind. Much as I wish to defend the gay community, I also want to defend freedom of conscience, expression and religion,” he wrote.

“Gareth Lee’s legal case against Ashers was backed by the Equality Commission of Northern Ireland. It argued that the bakery’s actions breached Northern Ireland’s Equality Act and Fair Employment and Treatment Order, which prohibit discrimination in the provision of goods, facilities and services on the respective grounds of sexual orientation and political opinion. Last May a Belfast court found Ashers guilty of discrimination on both grounds, ordering it to pay Lee £500 compensation,” he wrote.

“I profoundly disagree with Ashers’ opposition to same-sex love and marriage, and support protests against them. … Nevertheless, on reflection the court was wrong to penalize Ashers and I was wrong to endorse its decision,” he wrote.

“The lawsuit against the bakery was well-intended. It sought to challenge homophobia. But it was a step too far. It pains me to say this, as a long-time supporter of the struggle for LGBT equality in Northern Ireland, where same-sex marriage and gay blood donors remain banned. The equality laws are intended to protect people against discrimination. A business providing a public service has a legal duty to do so without discrimination based on race, gender, faith and sexuality.

“However, the court erred by ruling that Lee was discriminated against because of his sexual orientation and political opinions. … His cake request was refused not because he was gay, but because of the message he asked for. There is no evidence that his sexuality was the reason Ashers declined his order,” he wrote.

Such a conclusion is a bad precedent, he said. “Northern Ireland’s laws against discrimination on the grounds of political opinion were framed in the context of decades of conflict. They were designed to heal the sectarian divide by preventing the denial of jobs, housing and services to people because of their politics. There was never an intention that this law should compel people to promote political ideas with which they disagreed.”

He continued: “This raises the question: should Muslim printers be obliged to publish cartoons of Mohammed? Or Jewish ones publish the words of a Holocaust denier? Or gay bakers accept orders for cakes with homophobic slurs? If the Ashers verdict stands it could, for example, encourage far-right extremists to demand that bakeries and other service providers facilitate the promotion of anti-migrant and anti-Muslim opinions. It would leave businesses unable to refuse to decorate cakes or print posters with bigoted messages.”

The Christian Institute recently posted a video of the key managers of the bakery, Daniel and Amy McArthur, explaining that the lower court decision appeared to have been made before evidence was presented. “They wanted to teach us a lesson. … If you’re a Christian, don’t bring it into work,” they said. See the statement:

Earlier, the
institute said a top legal expert was joining the team defending Ashers. Professor Christopher McCrudden of Queen's University Belfast, who studied law at Yale and Oxford and specializes in human rights law, joined the team already led by David Scoffield.

In the Colorado case, attorneys how have argued that the finding of discrimination against baker Jack Phillips has to be overturned. The argument is being raised in a friend-of-the-court brief filed by William J. Olson P.C., in the case against Masterpiece Cake shop and its owner, Jack Phillips. Phillips was accused of discrimination for not providing the pro-"gay" cake, and an administrative law judge found he had discriminated. A district court came to the same conclusion.

He was ordered to stop the discrimination and send all of his employees to an indoctrination course.

However, the new brief argues the state's own records contradict the state Court of Appeals finding that "by refusing to sell a wedding cake 'because of [a same sex couple's] intent to engage in a same-sex ceremony,' Masterpiece Cake shop violated the Colorado Anti-Discrimination Act."


In fact, the administrative law judge who first heard the complaint was specific in his findings, which have been undisputed throughout the case, the brief explains. The judge found that Phillips had a consistent business policy based on his religious beliefs, which was the foundation for refusing to make the cake.

The judge found:
       "Phillips has been a Christian for approximately 35 years, and believes in Jesus Christ as his Lord and savior. As a Christian, Phillips' main goal in life is to be obedient to Jesus and His teachings in all aspects of his life."
·        "Based on the teachings of the Bible, Phillips 'believes … that God's intention for marriage is the union of one man and one woman.'"
·        "Phillips 'believes that the Bible commands him to avoid doing anything that would displease God, and not to encourage sin in any way.'"
·        "Phillips believes that decorating cakes is a form of art and creative expression, and that he can honor God through his artistic talents."
·        "Phillips 'believes that if he uses his artistic talents to participate in same-sex weddings by creating a wedding cake, he will be displeasing God and acting contrary to the teachings of the Bible.'"
·        "Phillips 'advised' the mother of one of the persons in the same-sex couple 'that he does not create wedding cakes for same-sex weddings because of his religious beliefs, and because Colorado does not recognize same-sex marriages.'"

But the brief says the administrative law judge then "inexplicably and erroneously concluded that Phillips and Masterpiece refused to bake and sell a wedding cake to a same-sex couple 'because of [that couple's] sexual orientation.'"


The administrative law judge's own findings "undisputedly establish a consistent and comprehensive business policy encompassing a biblical stand against a wide range of biblical sins," the brief said

http://www.wnd.com/2016/02/gay-campaigner-i-was-wrong-about-christian-bakers/



Bank Deposits Unsafe

Please take a moment to read the special message from our advertising sponsor, Lear Capital, The Precious Metals Leaders. Our sponsors help us keep our news service free, though we do not necessarily endorse this message.

Greenspan warns and banks are preparing for the worst. Yes, the Countdown to Meltdown has begun. But there's hope…

"Here's How Alan Greenspan's '48-Year Old Secret' Can Help Save You From Financial Disaster"…

Former Fed Chairman, Alan Greenspan recently issued a dire warning that should be heeded by all U.S. citizens owning a savings account or retirement plan…He stated that the Fed cannot exit its era of Quantitative Easing without serious repercussions. According to insider reports, Greenspan warns there will be a "significant market event."   

And you can bet your bottom dollar he's not talking about yet another stock market record high. After all, we've had seven of them since the pre-crisis era. Discover what Greenspan is so afraid of… and… his "48-Year-Old Secret" to hedging financial harm here!

The sad fact is… that's not the only dangerous warning Greenspan has given lately. He has three more…

* The average American is unprepared to deal with inflation so high it could quadruple the cost of living.
                                                                     
* Food, gas, and energy could soon simply become unaffordable.
                                                                     
* The threat is like "a tinderbox of explosive inflation looking for a spark."

Major banking institutions around the world are taking the former 20-year Fed Chairman's warnings seriously. They are preparing for the worst case scenario.
                                                     
But here's the bad news…The Banks Are Taking Measures To Protect THEMSELVES From Utter Collapse… And Are NOT WORRIED About Your Precious Savings In Them!

Skeptical? It's happened already…Remember the recent crisis in the former financial "safe haven"… the country of Cyprus? When banks in Cyprus collapsed, a "bank holiday" was immediately declared.  The doors were locked and access to any money within the banks was cut off. While the banks were closed, it was determined that creditors of the bank--and NOT the taxpayers--would fund its bailout. Think of it as a "bail-in" and not a bailout. "Creditors" included shareholders, bond investors and--get this--The Bank's Own Depositors!

The news media covering the story claimed that "this could only happen in Cyprus." Wrong! Discover this vile threat to your financial future, along with Alan Greenspan's "48-Year-Old Secret" solution on this web page!

Little did they know that all the banks in the world were preparing for the next crisis by laying the foundation upon which they could implement their own "bail-in" strategy.
                                                     
All the while, geopolitical unrest is growing daily. The labor participation rate is shrinking. Housing data is growing weaker and weaker. Economies of the world are deflating around us.  Does this remind you of Greece?

Yes, Alan… you are totally correct. The global financial situation is getting more and more critical each and every day. Will the house of cards soon collapse? Fortunately, Alan Greenspan revealed the secret to help protect against these impending threats...48 Years Ago!

And we'd like to reveal the current crisis in its entirety… along with Alan Greenspan's 48-year-old secret on how to survive and prosper amidst the chaos… in an exclusive complimentary report entitled "Zero-Proof Your Savings and Retirement Before It's Too Late!"

Get your FREE report and discover Alan Greenspan's "48-Year-Old Secret" here!

Listen, the last crisis struck without warning. The next one will not. Consider yourself warned by a man who was once the most powerful banker in the world. Download your FREE report right now… you will get clear instructions on how to start hedging your life savings, retirement accounts, and any other investments you might have against the ravages of inflation—or worse.

Lear Capital Research Team

P.S. The "Countdown to Meltdown" has already started. Are you prepared?
Download your FREE "Zero-Proof Your Savings and Retirement Before It's Too Late!" report to see what you need to do… right now!

Newsmax.com



TPP is a Disaster

As TPP Signing Nears, Experts Warn U.S. Manufacturing Will Suffer, by Sen. Jeff Sessions 1/2/16

"The American Automobile Policy Council recently issued a report which stated that the TPP would threaten 90,000 American automotive jobs... Ford released a statement opposing the deal. They argued that the TPP is not adequately open and does not adequately open foreign markets to U.S. goods...The White House's own study...claimed that TPP will decrease the growth of manufacturing in the United States by 20 percent by 2030.

"We need to demand that people who sell in our markets--and whose exports to the United States are critical to their economic well-being--don't get to do this if they are not playing by the rules. They don't get to manipulate their currencies. They don't get to subsidize their manufacturing, and we are not going to allow them to use nontariff barriers to prohibit the imports of American products.

"A nation that has the greatest economy in the world, a nation that has the greatest military in the world must maintain a manufacturing base."

U.S. Senator Jeff Sessions (R-AL) serves on four Senate committees: Armed Services, Budget, Environment and Public Works, and Judiciary, where he is Chairman of the Subcommittee on Immigration and the National Interest.

Visit Sessions online at his website <http://sessions.senate.gov/public/>

Comments

Tell your Congressman and Senators to vote NO on TPP.


Norb Leahy, Dunwoody GA Tea Party Leader

Stop the Strong Cities Network!

By Tom DeWeese, 2/1/16, American Policy Center

You’ve been targeted by the U.S. Department of Justice as a threat to American cities! That’s because Attorney General Loretta Lynch says you are an “Extremist.”

To protect yourself and your family it’s URGENT that you sign the attached petition to House Speaker Paul Ryan to demand that he take immediate action to force Attorney General Lynch to stop her threats against you NOW! Here are the facts.

In September, 2015, at the United Nations, Attorney General Lynch announced that the United States is going to implement a new program called the “Strong Cities Network.”

This program is one of the most powerful and frightening threats to American freedom ever conceived. In fact, I believe the enforcement of the Strong Cities Network is high treason to the Constitution of the United States!

Lynch makes the Strong Cities Network sound like a plan to help cities prepare to defend themselves against radical Islamic terrorist. She said the Strong Cities Network is a plan for cities to join hands with others around the world to assure “extremism” is kept in check.

The truth is, the Strong Cities Network is the brainchild of a UN organization called the Institute for Strategic Dialog (ISD).

But according to the ISD, the target is what they call “Far Right Extremism.” In fact, the ISD actually thinks “Far Right Extremism” is actually a threat to Islam!

And what do they mean by “Far Right Extremism?” The ISD, and now Attorney General Lynch (representing the government of the United States) are “alarmed” about Conservative opposition to illegal immigration and our opposition to the nation being flooded with radical Islamists.
They call that “Far Right Extremism” and a ”threat to world peace.”

Do you oppose illegal immigration? Do you oppose the invasion of radical Islam into our country? Do you oppose the enforcement of Sharia Law in the United States?

Then you are a direct target of the Strong Cities Network.

Some now believe that this Obama-backed program will result in a United Nations police force on American soil.

I don’t know if that will happen. But I do know that at this very minute, the Southern Poverty Law Center (SPLC) is conducting training seminars for our local police forces to teach them about how to combat Domestic Terrorism.

In 2010, The SPLC issued a report entitled “Rage on the Right: The Year in Hate and Extremism.” What did they describe as acts of hate and extremism?

Opposition to Obamacare. Opposition to illegal immigration. Opposition to abortion. Opposition to gun control. Opposition to big government.

Click here to sign our petition to stop the Strong Cities Network (https://americanpolicy.wufoo.com/forms/k1b59h140yc1gyv/?mc_cid=947ef7bcbb&mc_eid=[UNIQID])

Click here for a Directory of Representatives (http://www.house.gov/representatives/?mc_cid=947ef7bcbb&mc_eid=[UNIQID])

And the Southern Poverty Law Center has contracts with the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) to define and target extremists.

Apparently the SPLC’s brand of extremism doesn’t include beheadings; burning people alive’ drowning them in a cage as they are slowly lowered into a pool; or targeting people of specific religions, such as Christians.

No – people like you are considered much more dangerous than radical Islamist terrorist, according to Loretta Lynch and the Strong Cities Network. Do you understand? The Strong Cities Network is Obama’s response to your opposition to his policies. The Strong Cities Network is designed to be a blockade around you!

That’s why I call it treason. Treason to the Constitution. Treason to every right and freedom America has ever stood for. It must be stopped now, before it can be fully implemented.

If you think this is simply a hollow alarm or a conspiracy theory, let me tell you, the American cities of New York, Denver, Atlanta and Minneapolis have already joined the Strong Cities Network. That means millions of Americans are already under its direct threat.

We cannot let this threat grow. It must be stopped.

That’s why it is urgent that you sign the attached petition to House Speaker Ryan to demand that he take immediate action to stop this monster now, before it can gain a foothold across the nation – before there are UN police patrolling our streets.

You may think that signing such a petition does no good. But I assure you that if thousands of Americans suddenly demand action – that demand is heard.

APC was able to get the SPLC to back down when it labeled Dr. Ben Carson an extremist. We did it by making a major protest.

APC has led the fight to get over 150 cities to drop their memberships in the UN group ICLEI, as it attempted to enforce Agenda 21 on them. In fact, the head of ICLEI USA reported that he is terrified of our movement because we made their very name political poison and they can’t get new American cities to join them!

With enough protest now, we can get those same cities to fight enforcement of the Strong Cities Network.

That’s what we can accomplish if we fight!

If we do nothing, then we will see our freedoms destroyed under this tyranny.

Please don’t let that happen. Please sign your petition to Speaker Ryan to demand that he take action to stop the Strong Cities Network.

We can win this fight.

And please, help me and APC lead this fight by supporting APC with your dollars. Your financial support is the only way I have to fund this effort. APC is effective. APC is a leader in the fight for freedom.

Together you and I can and we will stop the Strong Cities Network.

Click here to sign our petition to stop the Strong Cities Network (https://americanpolicy.wufoo.com/forms/k1b59h140yc1gyv/?mc_cid=947ef7bcbb&mc_eid=[UNIQID])

Click here for a Directory of Representatives (http://www.house.gov/representatives/?mc_cid=947ef7bcbb&mc_eid=[UNIQID])

Thank you, Tom DeWeese President

(http://americanpolicy.org/2016/01/25/stop-the-strong-cities-network/?mc_cid=947ef7bcbb&mc_eid=[UNIQID])


Stop UN Agenda 21 in Schools

Regionalism needs to be repealed, not expanded.

GOP-led states increasingly taking control from local school boards, by Lyndsey Layton, 2/1/16

Republican lawmakers in Illinois last month pitched a bold plan for the state to seize control of the Chicago public schools, becoming one of a growing number of states that are moving to sideline local officials — even dissolve locally elected school boards — and take over struggling urban schools.

Governors in Michigan, Arkansas, Nevada, Wisconsin, Georgia, Ohio and elsewhere — mostly Republican leaders who otherwise champion local control in their fights with the federal government — say they are intervening in cases of chronic academic or financial failure. They say they have a moral obligation to act when it is clear that local efforts haven’t led to improvement.


“I want to protect the schoolchildren and their parents; that’s my first duty,” Illinois Gov. Bruce Rauner (R) said about his plan, which would wrest control of the nation’s third-largest school district from elected city leaders and was immediately opposed “100 percent” by Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel (D).

After Ohio Gov. John Kasich, a Republican presidential hopeful, seized the struggling schools in Youngstown last July, he described it as an 11th-hour attempt to save young lives. “If you’re a school district that’s failed year after year after year, someone’s going to come riding to the rescue of kids,” Kasich said, describing the Youngstown school system, which has regularly received F’s on state report cards and where just 1.1 percent of the Class of 2013 was deemed ready for college.

Eleven states have passed or debated legislation to create state-run school districts in the past year, according to the Education Commission of the States, which tracks state education policy.

“There certainly is an effort afoot in the country to dismantle local government and reduce or eliminate the role of local school boards,” said Thomas Gentzel, executive director of the National School Boards Association.

State takeovers were once a rarity, but they have become increasingly popular as the number of states controlled by Republicans doubled between 2010 and 2014.

“There’s been a sea change of Republicans taking control of a great many states, and this model is quite appealing to them,” said Kenneth K. Wong, chair of the education department at Brown University.

In the most recent versions, states are creating “recovery districts” in which they take control of large numbers of schools scattered across several districts.

Although the particulars vary, an appointed manager wields broad powers to redesign schools or close them entirely. The state manager can hire and fire, set curriculum,

reconfigure the school day, sell property and, in some cases, break existing labor contracts. Increasingly, state managers are turning over traditional public schools to charter school operators, which are funded by tax dollars but are privately managed.

The idea is that the state can bring aggressive change in a way that local politicians, with their community ties and loyalties, cannot.

The best-known example is the Recovery School District in Louisiana, created by state lawmakers in 2003 to convert struggling traditional schools in New Orleans, Baton Rouge and Shreveport into charter schools. The district now consists of about 70 charter schools.

But the move to replace locally elected school officials with outsiders has yielded questionable results. Takeovers in Newark, Detroit and Memphis have not improved test scores — in fact, some schools have gone backward.

“These ideas kind of travel like wildfire,” said Kent McQuire, president and chief executive of the Southern Education Foundation, which recently analyzed state takeovers in three states. “But you can’t really find evidence that there’s been positive, sustainable changes in learning in those places.”

And the takeovers have sparked angry protests, legal challenges and bitter complaints of racism. All state takeovers to date have occurred in school districts that are impoverished and majority African American and Latino.

“These proposals are not really about school reform or improvement,” said Philip Lanoue, the 2015 national Superintendent of the Year. He runs a school district in Georgia, where Gov. Nathan Deal (R) wants to change the state constitution to enable state takeovers. “These takeovers are entangled with money and power and control.”


In Georgia, Deal wants to create an Opportunity School District made up of as many as 100 low-performing schools from across his state.

But voters first have to amend the state constitution, which currently stipulates that education must be controlled by “that level of government closest and most responsive to the taxpayers and parents of the children being educated.” If the referendum passes in November, Atlanta would be most affected, with 27 eligible struggling schools.

The mere threat of a takeover has prompted the Atlanta public schools to act. The system hired a top Deal education aide — who had designed the governor’s plan for takeovers — to advise the city on how to avoid one. Atlanta Superintendent Meria Carstarphen announced last month that she was inviting charter school operators, local nonprofit agencies and other organizations to submit proposals for ways to boost the performance of those 27 struggling schools.

One elementary school in Clarke County, Lanoue’s district, would be a candidate for takeover. He said lasting improvement doesn’t come from a top-down makeover.
“If you really wanted true reform, wouldn’t you work directly with school boards and the school system?” he said. One of the most contentious takeovers has been the seizure of the Youngstown City Schools in Ohio, which the Kasich administration orchestrated behind closed doors.

Youngstown has been struggling since the collapse of the steel industry in the 1970s. Nearly all the district’s 5,100 students are low-income, and 1 in 5 have special needs. Classrooms churn with instability: Nearly 20 percent of Youngstown students either came into the district or left in the middle of the 2013-2014 school year while more than 1 in 4 were chronically absent.

In the summer of 2014, Tom Humphries, president of the Youngstown/Warren Regional Chamber of Commerce and a Kasich supporter, said the governor told him to devise a plan to fix the schools.

“This is about these kids,” said Humphries, adding that the region has had difficulty attracting new employers because of an undereducated workforce. “They only get one opportunity, and this is about their lives. We can’t keep doing the same things. They’re not working.”

He launched 10 months of secret meetings between top Kasich administration officials and a handful of community leaders, including the Youngstown schools superintendent and the president of Youngstown State University.

Participants’ notes released by the state show the members pledging secrecy out of concern for anticipated public resistance. After nearly a year of discussions, the Kasich administration unveiled plans for a turbocharged state takeover that includes the dissolution of the locally elected school board and appointment of a chief executive officer with broad powers over local schools. A special commission controlled by Kasich appointees is expected to name a chief executive next month.

The administration and its allies in the state legislature rushed the legislation, getting it approved by a committee and narrowly passed by both houses of the legislature less than 24 hours after it was made public, drawing protests from Democratic lawmakers who said it violated procedure.

“This was a blueprint to dismantle the city schools,” said state Sen. Joe Schiavoni, a Democrat who represents Youngstown and is Senate minority leader.

Members of the elected Youngstown school board said they were blindsided. “None of our community was involved in this, period,” said Brenda Kimble, president of the Youngstown City Schools board of education, which is suing to stop the takeover. “No board members, no parents, no elected officials, no teaching staff. Nobody knew about this.”

The Rev. Kenneth Simon, a Baptist pastor involved with Youngstown schools, said the changes concentrate power in a new chief executive who is not accountable to the community, something that could be especially damaging to African Americans.

“They’re taking away the right of our own school board that we elected to govern,” he said. “The school board has no power,” he said. “The community has no say. I don’t know how African Americans could sit and let them roll the clock back like this.”

The law applies not just to Youngstown but to any Ohio school district that receives an F grade from the state three years in a row.

“This isn’t just something happening in this small city in Ohio,” said Schiavoni, the Democratic lawmaker. “This is going to happen in other school districts in Ohio, and it’s happening all over the country. It’s a systematic approach to privatize public education.”

Talking to reporters four months ago, Kasich was baffled that some in the community oppose the takeover of a failing school district.

“What do they want to do? They want kids to continue to fail?” Kasich said. “People ought to be outraged when kids are trapped in failing schools. It’s a disgrace.”


Comments

I oppose further state intrusion into K-12 public education in Georgia and recommend a “NO” vote on the GA Constitutional Amendment in November 2016.

US K-12 public schools need to be independent from federal government funding and control.  It is unconstitutional, dangerous and detrimental.

Georgia K-12 public schools need to be independent from state government funding and control. 

I oppose unelected governance.  I want to repeal Regionalism in Georgia to eliminate governance by appointed boards.  This includes the repeal of GA HB 1216 passed in 2010 and GA HB 277 passed in 2012.

I oppose Common Core, social engineering, admittance of non-English-speaking students and Muslim propaganda in public schools.

I support public school reform by making students responsible for their own education and giving parents and teachers the primary responsibility for assisting these students.  Teachers, parents and Principals should decide on curriculum, content and materials. I support the elimination of middle school and the restoration of the K-8 neighborhood grammar school.

I urge County School Systems to stop selling Bonds to fund construction and to plan maintenance and additions to expand the use of school buildings to 100 years.

Norb Leahy, Dunwoody GA Tea Party Leader